Minor ii-V-i Navigation
I've been doing a lot of work with Melodic Minor modes, specifically Lydian Dominant, Locrian #2, Altered Dominant (Super Locrian), and Melodic Minor itself. I abbreviate them as LD, L2, AD, and MM. LD isn't a big deal, as I only use it to color a standard dominant sound, and I'm pretty comfortable with that. It's the minor ii-V-i turnarounds that are giving me trouble, using L2 on the ii, AD on the V, and MM on the i.
Here's each scale's spelling:
MM: 1 2 b3 4 5 6 7
LD (4th mode of MM): 1 2 3 #4 5 6 b7
L2 (6th mode of MM): 1 2 b3 4 b5 b6 b7
AD (7th mode of MM): 1 b2 b3 b4 b5 b6 b7 = 1 b9 #9 3 b5 #5 b7
A major ii-V-I allows you to play the major scale of the I for the whole thing. (LD is the most consonant over the V, but you can get away with just the I major.) A minor ii-V-i is much trickier. The natural minor scale on the i is undesirable over all three chords. The ii chord is closest, but it usually calls for L2 instead of Locrian. The V chord is often altered to all hell, calling for Phrygian Major, Symmetric Dominant (Half-Whole Diminished), Whole Tone, or Altered Dominant. I default to AD (because it's simply 1, 3, b7, both altered 5ths, both altered 9ths) unless certain extensions are specified that preclude it. And finally, a minor chord functioning as tonic deserves nothing less than Melodic Minor.
Using L2 over the ii chord, AD over the V, and MM over the i requires rapid changes of context when this progression isn't given much time. These are all different scales; L2 on 2 is MM on 4, AD on 5 is MM on b6. So it's tough to cheat and use the same group of notes for the whole thing like the major ii-V-I.
I'm getting better at navigating through these three scales, but I need more material. So far I'm just improvising within the mental framework I'm building. I intend to grab some licks from my 1001 Jazz Licks book, and James Mahone just posted a number of minor ii-V ideas on his Practice Portal blog.
James Mahone (27 Dec 2009 at 10:07pm)
Hello Joe,
Thanks for mentioning my blog on your blog. I just wanted to let you know that my URL has changed. it's now "http://www.jamesmahonemusic.com/wordpress". The old URL is a complete dud and will not redirect so please take note...
Thanks Again,
James M.
f.waltonjr (13 Feb 2011 at 9:44pm)
james,Iam trying to reach about some trascription of Booker Little.Frank
Gerald Nkhoma (17 May 2012 at 6:54am)
Hi Joe
I trust that you are well. I've just perused through your post on Minor ii-V-i Navigation. What do mean by; L2 on 2 is MM on 4, AD on 5 is MM on b6. I am at a complete loss as to the mechanics of what you are explaining.
Many thanks
Gerry
Joe (17 May 2012 at 7:14am)
Hi Gerald,
Thanks for the question. I admit that was a poor explanation on my part.
Start with thinking of a major ii-V-I in C. It goes Dm7-G7-Cmaj7. It's common to use D Dorian, G Mixolydian, and C Major over those three chords. Those three scales happen to contain all the same notes, so you can take a mental shortcut and play C Major over all three chords.
In the phrase you quoted, I was trying to illustrated that no such shortcut is available when using Melodic Minor modes over a minor ii-V-i. If you related all three scales back to the tonic, you're playing Locrian #2 built on the 2 of the tonic, Altered Dominant built on the 5 of the tonic, then Melodic Minor on the 1 of the tonic.
Putting this in the key of A minor:
B Locrian #2
E Altered Dominant
A Melodic Minor
If I convert each of these to their equivalent Melodic Minor mode, I get:
D Melodic Minor (the 4 of A)
F Melodic Minor (the b6 of A)
A Melodic Minor